Limits of Applicability
The T′-expansion scheme is a leading-order resummation of the Taylor series in \(\hat{\mu} = \mu/T\), and its validity is therefore inherently limited to regimes where higher-order corrections remain small. Since the next-order contributions to \(T'(T, \hat{\mu})\) are not computed, there is no built-in convergence criterion available from within the expansion itself to assess where it breaks down.
In the pure finite-\(\mu_B\) direction, the expansion is expected to remain reliable up to \(\mu_B / T \lesssim 3.5\), consistent with the typical range of applicability of standard Taylor expansions at finite baryon density [1]. In other directions of the \((\mu_B, \mu_Q, \mu_S)\) space, this bound may differ, and no universal analytic criterion is currently available.
A practical and physically motivated approach to assess the usability of the resulting EoS is to verify that it satisfies the fundamental thermodynamic stability and causality conditions [2]. These represent necessary conditions for any physically acceptable equation of state, independently of the truncation order of the expansion.
Stability and Causality Conditions
Following the afore-mentioned arguments to assess the regions of the phase diagram where the EoS is physically acceptable, three conditions must be satisfied simultaneously:
1. Mechanical stability — positivity of the speed of sound
The squared isentropic speed of sound must be positive:
In the 4D-TExS framework, \(c_s^2\) is computed analytically in the \((T, \hat{\mu})\) plane. Treating the EoS as a 2-dimensional system at fixed direction \((\theta, \phi)\), it takes the form:
where \(\hat{s} = s/T^3\) is the dimensionless entropy density, \(X_1 = n/T^3\) is the dimensionless generalized charge density, and \(X_2 = \partial X_1/\partial\hat{\mu}\) is the generalized second-order susceptibility. All \(T\)-derivatives are dimensionless (normalized by appropriate powers of \(T\)) and computed via spline differentiation at fixed \(\hat{\mu}\).
2. Causality — subluminality
The speed of sound must not exceed the speed of light:
3. Thermodynamic stability — positive-definiteness of the Hessian matrix
In the 4D-TExS framework, thermodynamic stability is assessed in the reduced 2-dimensional \((T, \hat{\mu})\) plane at fixed direction \((\theta, \phi)\), rather than through the full \(4\times 4\) susceptibility matrix in \((T, \mu_B, \mu_Q, \mu_S)\) space. The relevant stability criterion is thus the positive-definiteness of the 2D Hessian matrix of the pressure with respect to \((T, \hat{\mu})\):
By Sylvester’s criterion, positive-definiteness of \(\mathcal{H}_{2D}\) requires both:
and
The T-derivatives \(\partial \hat{s}/\partial T\) and \(\partial X_1/\partial T\) are computed via spline differentiation of the dimensionless profiles \(s(T)/T^3\) and \(X_1(T)/T^3\) at fixed \(\hat{\mu}\). Note that \(\det(\mathcal{H}_{2D})\) also appears in the denominator of the speed of sound formula — a vanishing determinant signals both a thermodynamic instability and a divergence of \(c_s^2\).
Results
We show below, lying outside of contours drawn for several values of constant temperature (\(T = 100, 200, 300, 400, 500\) MeV), the regions where stability and/or causality conditions are violated for the three planes of finite \((\mu_B, \mu_Q)\), \((\mu_B, \mu_S)\), and \((\mu_Q, \mu_S)\) [2].
Caveats
It is important to stress that satisfying the stability and causality conditions is a necessary but not sufficient condition for the EoS to be reliable. The 4D-TExS is a leading-order expansion, and there is no guarantee that higher-order corrections are negligible in the region where \(c_s^2 \in (0,1]\) and \(\det(\mathcal{H}) > 0\). In particular, the expansion could break down at intermediate \(\hat{\mu}\) values where stability conditions are still formally satisfied, if the next-order coefficient \(\lambda_4^{\theta,\phi}(T)\) is large.
These conditions should therefore be understood as providing a conservative, physics-based estimate of the safe operating range of the module, rather than a rigorous proof of convergence of the expansion. When in doubt, comparing against HRG results at low \(T\) or against alternative methods in overlapping regions of the phase diagram is recommended as an additional cross-check.